You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
verify(fastmcp): native versus protocol tool descriptors (§10) #653
Complete the FastMCP §10 descriptor-attribute slice of the offline MCP/descriptor verification handoff. Distinguish native FastMCP tool objects from the MCP protocol tool representation rather than assuming both expose .inputSchema.
Plan
Install and inspect the MCP SDK's FastMCP and standalone fastmcp distribution, recording exact versions and package ownership.
Define a trivial native tool, assert the real name/description/schema accessors, and compare the framework's already-computed schema with its protocol tool representation without opening any MCP session.
Commit a reproducible sibling probe and output, correct the ledger and any code that names the disproven attributes, preserve the descriptor implementation guard, and document version-specific mismatches.
Run framework-free and all-framework gates separately, required lint/type/import checks, and synchronize the consumer boundary docs.
I am taking this work. Please assign the Verification milestone and appropriate testing/verification labels (fork contributor).
Thanks for filing this. We won't be working on it for now — the §9 MCP binding / §10 descriptor verification is deferred until Phase 2, when the features that consume it (#221, #222) start. See the note on the linked PR; we'll ping you when it's picked up.
Activity
tbolis-at-mulesoft commentedon Sep 26, 2026
Thanks for filing this. We won't be working on it for now — the §9 MCP binding / §10 descriptor verification is deferred until Phase 2, when the features that consume it (#221, #222) start. See the note on the linked PR; we'll ping you when it's picked up.