Skip to content

False interpretation for structures without CHIRAL flag by the SUCF parameter #221

Open

Description

@gblanke02

The parameter /SUCF is supposed to evaluate the Chiral flag information in V2 molfile to evaluate the stereochemistry of stereocenters. If the Chiral flag is set it means that the stereocenter of a compound is pure and known. If it is not set the compound is a racemic mixtures that contains both of the variations of the compounds. (See Biovia chemical representation guide and CTFile documentation).

While the case of a known and pure isomer corresponds to the parameter SAbs (used in standard InChI, resulting in “/s1” in the InChI string) the representation racemic mixture corresponds to the parameter SRac resulting in “/s3”.

With /SUCF a structure must be identified with /s1 if the Chiral flag is set but it should return “/s3” for racemic structures and not “/s2” (relative / OR case) as it does in the current implementation.

In the attached example (R)-bromo-chloro-fluoro-methane-Chiral.mol /SUCF returns correctly InChI=1/CHBrClF/c2-1(3)4/h1H/t1-/m0/s1.
But for (R)-bromo-chloro-fluoro-methane-Non-Chiral.mol /SUCF returns InChI=1/CHBrClF/c2-1(3)4/h1H/t1-/s2 (SRel case). Instead it is supposed to return InChI=1/CHBrClF/c2-1(3)4/h1H/t1-/s3 (SRac case).

(~{R})-bromo-chloro-fluoro-methane-Chiral.mol.txt
(~{R})-bromo-chloro-fluoro-methane-Non-Chiral.mol.txt

Activity

  1. fbaensch-beilstein commented on Jun 12, 2026

    @fbaensch-beilstein
    Collaborator

    @gblanke02 This is documented behavior, not an accidental bug:

    inchi_ios_print_nodisplay(f, " SUCF Use Chiral Flag: On means Absolute stereo, Off - Relative\n");

    nonetheless it is wrong.
    I can fix it if you want.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Labels

bugSomething isn't workingchemistrySomething related to chemistry

Type

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions