Add component-owner approval guard for issue #10 - #407
Conversation
|
Follow-up pushed in
Fresh local validation after this commit:
|
|
@algora-pbc /claim #10 Claim registration follow-up for active replacement PR #407. This PR body includes |
|
Reviewer-ready checkpoint for /claim #10. I rechecked the active claim state: this PR is open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, Bounty claim labeled, and the body contains /claim #10. It is the active replacement for the closed duplicate #387, with scope still limited to component-owner approval quorum before protected-branch merge or tagged release; validation and demo artifacts are included, with no credential/private-data expansion. |
|
Visibility update after PR #417: this existing Scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard, separate from the newer semantic version-tag governor. PR #407 covers required scientific component owner approvals for manuscript/data/code/notebooks/protocols/results/metadata changes before protected-branch merge or tagged release, including stale approval and conflicted self-approval checks. I do not see a contributor-side blocker for review/reward decision on this PR. |
|
Status refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity. Re-verified now: this PR is open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #10. The scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard: required scientific component owner approvals for manuscript/data/code/notebooks/protocols/results/metadata changes before protected-branch merge or tagged release, stale approval checks, and conflicted self-approval checks. This is distinct from the newer external reference pinning and semantic version-tag slices. No implementation changes are needed from my side unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity. Re-verified now: this PR is open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #10. The scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard: required scientific component owner approvals for manuscript/data/code/notebooks/protocols/results/metadata changes before protected-branch merge or tagged release, stale approval checks, and conflicted self-approval checks. This is distinct from the newer notebook output diff gate, external reference pinning, and semantic version-tag slices. No implementation changes are needed from my side unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR activity, including PR #300. Re-verified now: this PR remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #10. The submitted scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard: required scientific component owner approvals for manuscript/data/code/notebooks/protocols/results/metadata changes before protected-branch merge or tagged release, stale approval checks, and conflicted self-approval checks. This is distinct from branch hypothesis lineage, notebook output diff, external reference pinning, and semantic version-tag slices. |
|
Status refresh after the newer issue-side claim refresh for PR #425: PR #407 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #10. The submitted scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard: required scientific component owner approvals for manuscript/data/code/notebooks/protocols/results/metadata changes before protected-branch merge or tagged release, stale approval checks, and conflicted self-approval checks. This is distinct from PR #425's repository external reference pinning guard and claim-format refresh, PR #429's notebook output diff gate, PR #417's semantic version-tag governor, restore rehearsal, compute sandbox, legal-hold, sensitive-artifact, dependency-license, and other repository/version-control slices. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after PR #425's newer hardening update: PR #407 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #10. The submitted scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard: required scientific component owner approvals for manuscript/data/code/notebooks/protocols/results/metadata changes before protected-branch merge or tagged release, stale approval checks, and conflicted self-approval checks. This is distinct from PR #425's repository external reference pinning guard and its latest durable-identifier hardening update, PR #429's notebook output diff gate, PR #417's semantic version-tag governor, restore rehearsal, compute sandbox, legal-hold, sensitive-artifact, dependency-license, and other repository/version-control slices. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless reviewers request revisions. |
|
Status refresh after newer same-issue PR #450 repository integrity auditor activity. PR #407 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, claim-marked for issue #10, and present in the Algora issue table. Scope remains unchanged and distinct: repository component-owner approval quorum guard for Project Repository & Version Control. It covers required scientific component owner approval, approval quorum, stale or missing approvals, high-risk repository actions, and reviewer-ready evidence before protected repository/version-control actions proceed. This is separate from the newer repository integrity auditor and other adjacent #10 slices. No implementation changes are needed unless reviewers request them. |
|
Status refresh after the newer same-issue PR #463 activity: PR #407 remains open, non-draft, mergeable/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, claim-marked for issue #10, and present in the Algora issue table. The submitted scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard: required scientific component owner approvals for manuscript/data/code-impacting repository changes, blocked self-approval paths, stale review detection, quorum evidence, and deterministic approval audit output before release/export. PR #463 appears to add a separate fork provenance and attribution auditor for dropped upstream contributor attribution, ambiguous merge bases, unreviewed history rewrites, DOI/tag/export drift, export manifest hash mismatches, derivative license conflicts, and stale citation badges. That is adjacent, but PR #407 is still the prior component-owner approval quorum layer for this issue. |
|
Visibility refresh after new same-issue PR #475 activity on issue #10. This existing submission remains PR #407, open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, and tied to the Pending USD 500 Algora claim: https://algora.io/claims/MvNKk26EabZwTUUv Maintainer review target remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard implemented here: required scientific component owner approvals for manuscript/data/code/notebooks/protocols/results/metadata changes before protected-branch merge. |
|
Visibility refresh after later same-issue PR #392 activity on May 29. This existing submission remains PR #407, open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, Maintainer review target remains the component-owner approval quorum guard implemented here: required scientific component owner approvals for manuscript/data/code/notebooks/protocols/results/metadata changes before protected repository/version-control actions. That scope is separate from PR #392's compute sandbox policy guard. |
|
Visibility refresh after the newer same-issue PR #493 claim registration. This existing submission remains PR #407, open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, Maintainer review target remains the repository component-owner approval guard: component-owner approval quorum for manuscript, data, code, notebooks, protocols, results, and metadata paths; fresh eligible approval coverage; restricted data/protocol escalation owners; stale approval handling after file movement; and conflicted self-approval blocking. PR #493 appears to add a separate repository embargo release guard for embargo expiry, funder/publication exceptions, access group cleanup, DOI/export parity, and citation badge visibility; PR #407 remains the prior component-owner approval quorum layer. |
|
Visibility refresh after PR #425's newer hardening pass for future-dated external-reference verification evidence. My existing issue #10 submission remains PR #407: #407 Current status re-verified now: PR #407 is open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, includes Scope reminder for review: PR #407 is the repository component-owner approval quorum guard for Project Repository & Version Control. It covers component-owner approval quorum for manuscript, data, code, notebooks, protocols, results, and metadata paths; fresh eligible approval coverage; restricted data/protocol escalation owners; stale approval handling after file movement; and conflicted self-approval blocking before protected repository/version-control actions proceed. This remains separate from PR #425's external-reference pinning and timestamp-freshness hardening, PR #493's repository embargo release guard, PR #392's compute sandbox policy guard, and other adjacent #10 slices. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after PR #425's newer hardening pass for future-dated API snapshot evidence. My existing issue #10 submission remains PR #407: #407 Current status re-verified now: PR #407 is open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, includes Scope reminder for review: PR #407 is the repository component-owner approval quorum guard for Project Repository & Version Control. It covers component-owner approval quorum for manuscript, data, code, notebooks, protocols, results, and metadata paths; fresh eligible approval coverage; restricted data/protocol escalation owners; stale approval handling after file movement; blocked conflicted self-approval; unmapped path coverage; and deterministic reviewer artifacts. This remains separate from PR #425's external-reference pinning / future-dated API snapshot evidence slice, PR #493's repository embargo release guard, PR #475's release signature guard, and the other same-issue repository/version-control slices. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 competitor PR #425 activity. This PR #407 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-listed, and claim-marked for issue #10. Scope remains distinct: component-owner approval quorum guard: component path ownership, fresh eligible approvals, restricted data/protocol escalation owners, stale approval handling, self-approval blocking, and unmapped path coverage. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG's latest PR #425 update ( PR #407 remains my active issue #10 submission: open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, Scope remains distinct: PR #407 is the repository component-owner approval quorum guard for protected repository/version-control actions. It covers component path ownership, fresh eligible approvals, restricted data/protocol escalation owners, stale approval handling, conflicted self-approval blocking, unmapped path coverage, and deterministic reviewer artifacts. PR #425 is a separate external-reference pinning/checksum-evidence slice. No contributor-side code changes are pending for PR #407 unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 competitor PR activity from KoiosSG PR #425. This PR #407 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #10. It is tied to the Pending USD 500 Algora claim: https://algora.io/claims/MvNKk26EabZwTUUv Scope remains distinct: repository component-owner approval quorum, fresh eligible approval coverage, restricted data/protocol escalation owners, stale approval handling after file movement, conflicted self-approval blocking, unmapped path coverage, and reviewer artifacts. PR #425 remains a separate external-reference pinning slice. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG's newer PR #425 update ( PR #407 remains my active issue #10 submission: open, non-draft, MERGEABLE/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, Scope remains distinct: repository component-owner approval quorum, fresh eligible approval coverage, restricted data/protocol escalation owners, stale approval handling after file movement, conflicted self-approval blocking, unmapped path coverage, and deterministic reviewer artifacts. PR #425 is a separate external-reference pinning/checksum/DOI evidence slice. No contributor-side code changes are pending for PR #407 unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity from @KoiosSG in PR #425 (repository external reference pin guard). PR #407 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for #10. Algora reward link remains indexed: https://algora.io/claims/MvNKk26EabZwTUUv Scope remains the component-owner approval guard, separate from PR #425's repository external reference pin guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #10 PR #425 later than my last PR #407 status. This active claim remains PR #407. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the repository component-owner approval guard: component path ownership, fresh eligible approvals, restricted data/protocol escalation owners, stale approval handling, conflicted self-approval blocking, unmapped path coverage, deterministic reviewer packets, and demo artifacts. This remains separate from PR #425's repository external-reference pinning/checksum/DOI evidence slice. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity from @Entr0zy / PR #500. PR #407 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE/CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #10. Its Algora claim remains Pending for USD 500: https://algora.io/claims/MvNKk26EabZwTUUv Scope remains the component-owner approval quorum guard before protected branch merge or tagged repository release. It is separate from PR #500's branch-protection drift guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR activity from @codeaustral-oss / PR #300. PR #407 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #10. Its Algora claim remains Pending for USD 500: https://algora.io/claims/MvNKk26EabZwTUUv Scope remains the component-owner approval quorum guard before protected branch merge or tagged repository release. It is separate from PR #300's repository branch hypothesis lineage gate. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
Visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity from @orenodinner / PR #503 at #10 (comment). This PR remains my active #10 submission. Current status re-verified now:
No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity from @attaboy11 at #10 (comment). This PR #407 remains my active issue #10 submission. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard, separate from the newer Git LFS pointer integrity and quota guard attempt. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR activity from @attaboy11 / PR #507: #507 This PR #407 remains my active issue #10 submission. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard, separate from PR #507's Git LFS pointer integrity and quota guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after the latest same-issue #10 PR update from @Entr0zy / PR #500: #500 This PR #407 remains my active issue #10 submission. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the component-owner approval quorum guard, separate from PR #500's branch-protection drift guard. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR update from @KoiosSG / PR #425: #425 This PR #407 remains my active issue #10 submission. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the component-owner approval quorum guard, separate from PR #425's repository external-reference pin guard. |
|
Merge/reward readiness refresh for /claim #10. Current contributor-side status rechecked from the watcher:
Could a maintainer please review this PR for merge/reward decision, or point me to the exact change needed to unblock it? I can respond quickly. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity from @jaxassistant55: #10 (comment) This PR #407 remains my active issue #10 submission. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard, separate from the newer repository automation credential rotation guard attempt. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR activity from @jaxassistant55 / PR #528: #528 This PR #407 remains my active issue #10 submission. Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard, separate from PR #528's repository automation credential rotation guard. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side reward-claim trace refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR activity from @KoiosSG / PR #425: PR #407 remains the active reward claim for issue #10. Current status re-verified now: open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, and This is not WIP on my side; it is ready for maintainer review and reward/merge decision. Scope remains the component-owner approval quorum guard, separate from PR #425's external reference pin guard. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR activity from @AlonePenguin / PR #537: #537 My active #10 submission remains PR #407: #407 Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains distinct: PR #407 is the repository component-owner approval quorum guard before protected branch merge or tagged repository release, covering component path ownership, fresh eligible approvals, restricted data/protocol escalation owners, stale approval handling, conflicted self-approval blocking, unmapped path coverage, and deterministic reviewer artifacts. PR #537 focuses on preserving resolved review-decision provenance into release/export records, which is adjacent #10 work but does not replace PR #407's component-owner approval layer. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity from @AlonePenguin:
This active #10 submission remains PR #407: #407 Current status re-verified now:
Scope remains the repository component-owner approval quorum guard before protected branch merge or tagged repository release. The newer release-note claim evidence attempt is adjacent #10 work but does not replace PR #407's component-owner approval layer. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity from @Jorel97:
This PR #407 remains my active issue #10 reward claim. Current status re-verified now: open, non-draft, mergeable clean, |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR activity from @Jorel97:
This PR #407 remains my active issue #10 reward claim. Current status re-verified now: open, non-draft, mergeable clean, |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR activity from codeaustral-oss PR #300:
This active #10 submission remains PR #407. Current status re-verified now: open, non-draft, mergeable clean, bounty claim label present, /claim #10 present, and Algora Pending for USD 500: https://algora.io/claims/MvNKk26EabZwTUUv Scope remains the component-owner approval guard, distinct from the newer same-issue PR activity listed above. |
|
Reward-readiness refresh after newer same-issue #10 PR activity from @KoiosSG / PR #425: This PR remains my active #10 reward claim and is still ready for maintainer review. Re-verified now:
Scope remains distinct: this PR covers repository component-owner approval quorum before protected branch merge or tagged repository release. PR #425 covers immutable external-reference pinning and timestamp-freshness for external repository/data/model references. Adjacent, not overlapping. No contributor-side changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions. |
|
PR-side visibility refresh after newer same-issue #10 activity. My active #10 reward claim remains this PR #407: #407 Current state re-verified by the watcher:
Newer same-issue PRs observed after this PR's last update:
Scope remains this submitted PR's focused implementation and evidence trail. No maintainer-side requested changes are visible from my side at this check; happy to adjust quickly if maintainers want a specific revision. |
1 participant
/claim #10
Closes #10
Summary
Adds
repository-component-owner-approval-guard, a self-contained Project Repository & Version Control slice that validates component-owner approval quorum before protected-branch merge or tagged repository release.The guard evaluates:
Distinct scope
This submission specifically covers component-owner approval quorum and approval freshness before merge. It is separate from broad repository ledgers, release engines, diff/rollback, provenance attestation, embargo gates, notebook replay, schema migration, citation verification, merge queues, environment drift, access review, metadata readiness, external-reference pinning, sensitive-artifact scanning, dependency licensing, legal hold, restore rehearsal, and compute-sandbox workflows.
PR #407 is the active review-ready submission and supersedes closed duplicate PR #387.
Validation
Validated from
repository-component-owner-approval-guard/at head0b7cf3bb63101dfcc20c3a00539a56723fa560f6:npm run check npm test npm run demo npm run demo:videoAll commands passed after the reproducibility-hardening commits.
Reviewer artifacts:
reports/summary.jsonreports/reviewer-packet.mdreports/summary.svgreports/demo.webmreports/demo.mp4requirements-map.mdSafety and disclosure
All inputs are synthetic. The module does not call Git providers, repository-hosting APIs, identity systems, storage systems, private repositories, or external services. It contains no private research data, credentials, real users, or live project mutations.
AI-assisted implementation; the committed behavior and evidence were validated with the commands above.
Claim record
No contributor-side changes are currently pending.