Skip to content

Unable to generate the structure for cycloprop-1-en-3-ylidene-1-nitrile #274

Open

Description

@vthimmakondu

While OPSIN generates the structure if I type the name like cycloprop-1-en-1-nitrile (or simply cyclopropen-1-nitrile) , it complains that
nitrile is uninterpretable as soon as a carbene comes into the picture. Any thoughts?

I believe that nitrile takes precedence over carbene in functional group ordering. Please, let me know if I am wrong about this. Of course, if I do use "cyano" as prefix (1-cyanocycloprop-1-en-3-ylidene) then I could generate the structure. But, is that correct way of naming?

Activity

  1. dan2097 commented on May 31, 2025

    @dan2097
    Owner

    As far as I'm aware the carbene takes precedence:
    https://iupac.qmul.ac.uk/BlueBook/P4.html
    According to that list radicals are the most preferred of all functional groups, while nitriles are rank 14.

    So I think 1-cyanocycloprop-1-en-3-ylidene would be the preferred name.

    IUPAC nomenclature does support a seldom used prefix ylo for indicating a radical using a prefix, but this is not supported by OPSIN.

  2. vthimmakondu commented on Jun 1, 2025

    @vthimmakondu
    Author

    Thank you. But, I am dealing with singlet carbenes here. They are NOT triplet carbenes. Electronic structure calculations that I did indicate that it is indeed a singlet. A triplet carbene could be considered as a biradical. But, what about singlet carbenes? Should we still consider them as radicals?

  3. dan2097 commented on Jun 2, 2025

    @dan2097
    Owner

    I don't think IUPAC nomenclature directly allows the distinction between single and triplet carbenes to be captured:

    "Systematic names are the preferred IUPAC names. The retained names carbene or methylene, nitrene or aminylene and carbyne, can be used in general nomenclature, with full substitution. The use of the systematic or retained names does not imply a specific electronic configuration. If needed, such a distinction would be made by using a separate word such as singlet or triplet, or a descriptive phrase."
    Source: https://iupac.qmul.ac.uk/BlueBook/P7.html#71020201

  4. vthimmakondu commented on Jun 4, 2025

    @vthimmakondu
    Author

    Thank you.

  5. vthimmakondu commented on Jun 25, 2025

    @vthimmakondu
    Author

    Should the preferred IUPAC name for this carbene should be should be 1-cyanocycloprop-1-en-3-ylidene (as you stated earlier) or should it be 2-cyanocycloprop-2-en-1-ylidene? Because, if we have to give preference to carbene considering it as a radical (and thus functional group here) then 1-ylidene should be preferred than ending with 3-ylidene? Am i correct?

    Because, even for the simplest case like cyclopropenylidene, the preferred IUPAC name is cycloprop-2-en-1-ylidene. Isn't it? If we use the same logic here then the preferred name should be 2-cyanocycloprop-2-en-1-ylidene. Please correct me if I am wrong about this.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions