You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
R/S descriptor builds the other configuration at one centre in some polycyclic names (CIP ranking differs from centres) #349
For a set of polycyclic names, OPSIN (2.9.0 and master 42e87ac6efb1) builds the stereoisomer that has the opposite
configuration at exactly one stereocentre. At that centre, SiMolecule/centres and RDKit's new CIP labeler
(rdCIPLabeler, a port of centres) give the descriptor written in the name; when they label OPSIN's output, they give
the other letter. Legacy RDKit agrees with them in most cases. So the difference seems to be in how the substituents of
that centre are ranked, not in the name.
Example 1 (centre 8; the tie between the cinnoline C-8a and the pyrimidin-4-yl carbon is in mancude rings, P-92.1.4.4):
In a sample of 1,899 polycyclic structures, 142 names show this pattern (one centre; centres and rdCIPLabeler agree
with each other). In #217 you mentioned possibly integrating centres; these could serve as test cases for that. Happy to
send the full list.
This appears to be due to a lack of support for atomic number averaging in mancude rings in OPSIN's CIP implementation. I'm not immediately sure whether it makes sense to implement this functionality into the existing code or dump the code entirely and simply use centres in all cases. @Kohulan Would it be possible to email me the complete list.
Activity
dan2097 commentedon Nov 2, 2026
This appears to be due to a lack of support for atomic number averaging in mancude rings in OPSIN's CIP implementation. I'm not immediately sure whether it makes sense to implement this functionality into the existing code or dump the code entirely and simply use centres in all cases.
@Kohulan Would it be possible to email me the complete list.