Skip to content

Adduct names: a leading radical component, hydrogen-ion words and isotope-labelled dihydrogen are not read #358

Open

Description

@Kohulan

Three forms in adduct names are not read. OPSIN main (3.0-SNAPSHOT, 7b756a1), radicals allowed:

1. A radical component that is not the last component is read as a prefix of the next component.

Name OPSIN main Expected
ethane—methyl (1/1) [CH3].CC (read)
methyl—ethane (1/1) "OPSIN believes there to be 1 components but 2 ratios" [CH3].CC
methylidene—ethane (1/1) same message [CH2].CC
nitroso—ethane (1/1) same message [N]=O.CC
ethane—methyl—ethyl (1/1/1) "2 components but 3 ratios" CC.[CH3].[CH2]C
dihydrogen—water (1/1) "uninterpretable: - water" (water—dihydrogen (1/1) reads) [H][H].O

The em dash already separates the components. The IUPAC 2013 recommendations put a radical first: P-14.8.1
"Organic adducts", "the individual components are cited in the order of seniority of classes (see P-41)", and
radicals are class 1 of P-41, Table 4.1 "General compound classes listed in decreasing order of seniority". Water is cited last (P-14.8.1, mixed adducts: "water (if present), is cited last").
So a name in the order of the recommendations has the radical first and cannot be read in that order, and a name with
two radical components cannot be read in any order.

2. The names of the hydrogen cations are not read.

Name OPSIN 2.9.0 and main Expected
hydride, deuteride read
hydron "uninterpretable: hydron" [H+]
proton "uninterpretable: proton" [1H+]
deuteron "uninterpretable: n" [2H+]
triton "uninterpretable: triton" [3H+]
chloride—hydron (1/1) "uninterpretable: hydron" [Cl-].[H+]

P-81.3 "Names for hydrogen atoms and ions", Table 8.1: cation H+ proton (1H), deuteron (2H), triton (3H),
hydron (natural composition); anion protide, deuteride, tritide, hydride.

3. Isotope-labelled dihydrogen is not read.

Name OPSIN 2.9.0 and main Expected
dihydrogen read
dichloro(2H2)methane read
(2H2)dihydrogen "uninterpretable: (2H2)dihydrogen" [2H][2H]
(2H1)dihydrogen same [2H][H]
(3H2)dihydrogen same [3H][3H]
(2H1,3H1)dihydrogen same [2H][3H]

P-82.2.1 "Isotopically substituted compounds": "The name of an isotopically substituted compound is formed by adding or
inserting the nuclide symbol(s) enclosed in parentheses ... before the part of the compound that is isotopically
substituted" (dichloro(2H2)methane (PIN)).

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions