Repository navigation
[LIMITED] QA: plugin skills in mid-message slash completion (#15662) #41
Description
Goal
Qualify a bounded downstream test of actual plugin-skill discovery output through slash-menu deduplication and mid-message query matching.
Context
Origin pingdotgg#15662 claims to address the real plugin-skill mid-message report pingdotgg#19847. Current source tests filesystem discovery and manually constructed composer skills separately. No runtime gap or defect is asserted yet. Preserve Maria’s implementation and Moinax/shivamhwp precursor credit.
Acceptance
First qualify the pinned workspace with official pnpm11.10.0, frozen lockfile and committed patches, skipping lifecycle scripts. Limit source/tooling/store/dependency allocation to2GiB and setup/qualification to10minutes. Stop on unavailable native prerequisites or skipped-script requirements; do not substitute stubs or stock Vitest. Baseline: real Vite Plus runner over ClaudeSkills, providerSkills and composerSlashCommandSearch suites. If qualification succeeds, a separately reviewed focused test should connect discovered namespaced plugin inventory to “please use /impl”, deduplication and built-in-command exclusion after ordinary text. This is inventory-to-search QA, not browser E2E or implementation ownership.
Return
Exact source/tool versions, commands, counts, logs/hashes, independent review and scoped conclusion, or precise prerequisite blocker. No provider credentials, upstream writes, main changes, paid compute, global settings, or unrelated existing claims.
Activity
kvnloo commentedon Oct 15, 2026
Claiming only the bounded assistant-sandbox setup and existing three-suite baseline qualification described above: maximum 10 minutes and 2 GiB newly allocated storage, frozen dependencies, no lifecycle scripts. One worker; no origin implementation claim or global-capacity assertion. Preserve the exact lockfile and patches; retain failure evidence and stop at a prerequisite or permission block without alternate-route retries. Further test editing requires successful setup qualification and a separate scope update.
kvnloo commentedon Oct 15, 2026
Phase one stopped at the predeclared early disk guard: 1,614,909,440 allocated bytes, below its 2 GiB limit. Exact source and three target test blobs verified; local pnpm 11.10.0 integrity verified. Frozen install had added 509/1,085 selected packages when stopped. Zero tests ran. Sealed phase-one manifest SHA-256:
df395f39ef52fdcb9305ef8e91b627036052cde431a52f806fd207125e0f3b54.This was solely our resource watchdog, with no permission denial, registry failure or observed toolchain mismatch. Current host has 23.84 GiB free. Explicitly extending this same one-worker scope for one resumed install attempt, at most 10 additional minutes and 6 GiB cumulative leaf allocation (early stop at 5 GiB). Keep separate phase-two logs, preserve phase-one evidence, the exact frozen lockfile and official pinned tooling. Still no lifecycle scripts; stop if they are required, or on permission/dependency failure. Run only the three previously named real baseline suites if setup finishes within budget. No new-test edits, provider calls, default-branch mutation, or origin action.
kvnloo commentedon Oct 15, 2026
Pinned environment is now executable: resumed frozen install completed with lifecycle scripts disabled. Real baseline passed 46/46 tests in 3/3 files: ClaudeSkills 23, providerSkills 16, composerSlashCommandSearch 7; exit 0. Cumulative allocation about 2.42 GiB.
Extending this same worker to the originally described focused discovery-to-search regression, test-only in an isolated feature branch. Preserve existing tests and source; use real temporary plugin files, actual discovery, inventory deduplication and search functions. Check namespaced implement completion mid-message and built-in exclusion, then rerun the affected baseline. If a matched pre-fix comparison is safely feasible, record RED/GREEN; otherwise report coverage evidence without inventing a fixed defect. Limit this stage to 10 minutes, retain the 6 GiB cumulative allocation cap, and require independent review before any branch publication. No production change, origin post, provider call or additional dependency installation.
kvnloo commentedon Oct 15, 2026
Completed and released this worker’s setup/test-only claim. Exact-head requirement gap independently reproduced: actual plugin discovery succeeds, but the literal same-line prompt
please use /implproduces no composer trigger. The prior-lineplease use\n/implcontrol passes through discovery, inventory collision removal and search. Issue pingdotgg#19847 explicitly requests same-line behavior; this does not establish browser behavior or current-main behavior.Published opt-in diagnostic and receipt on the isolated evidence branch. Verified remote SHA
1eed7a0ee14d697103cef018db144b305be3c86e, both files byte-for-byte, and exactly two added evidence files. Diagnostic is.ts.txt, excluded from normal test discovery. All production/base files preserved; downstream main remains339179f50a84dc599cce373dbb48f172f182f44e.Executed counts:
Independent reviewer reproduced the final bytes offline, confirmed all 27,746 original source files unchanged, and caught a test-registration style issue corrected before final rerun. Final formatter passed. Lint could not load missing
@oxlint/plugins; scoped typecheck reports TS6307 for importing server source from the web composite project. These packaging limitations are explicit; this is not a merge-ready default regression. Raw logs stay local; their hashes and reproduction commands are preserved in the remote receipt.Credit: Maria (
maria-rcks) owns the plugin-discovery implementation; Moinax and shivamhwp retain precursor credit. No origin post, default-branch mutation, merge or new credentials. Next useful step is current-main/actual-browser reconciliation before proposing a narrowly scoped trigger change.kvnloo commentedon Oct 15, 2026
Current-source reconciliation changes the next step: Bil0000’s pingdotgg#19107 already merged same-line slash trigger support on October 13. Both issue-era main
339179f50a84dc599cce373dbb48f172f182f44eand refreshed main3ff452bd65adf758e68b886d1e3778ae1ec7d970contain it. The earlier executed failure remains valid for Maria’s old PR head only; it does not justify a duplicate main trigger patch.Claiming bounded QA of GitHub’s existing synthetic merge
99b5739268a9aeb1fc9ae9251984892341b74fcd, parents2d31acb9751d89fd00f2b3fd0725b37ed9109440and owner headb633c9cae6af0a30a33a73ce7ce4cee5204e34b6. This merge is 21 commits behind refreshed main and is explicitly not current-main or browser validation. Discovery source/tests match the previously tested owner head; trigger/inventory/search source matches refreshed main.One setup/qualification attempt in a fresh sibling workspace: 10 minutes and 4 GiB new allocation, including shared-store growth; early stop 3.5 GiB. Frozen official dependencies, committed patches, lifecycle scripts disabled. Reuse only the pinned pnpm executable and official content-addressed store, never old node_modules. Run the three baseline suites plus web/shared trigger suites, then the same two-case opt-in diagnostic if time/resources permit. No production changes, reconstructed rebase, upstream action, provider call, personal computer or mutation of the old evidence workspace. Preserve Maria and precursor credit; Bil0000 owns the existing trigger implementation.
kvnloo commentedon Oct 15, 2026
Completed and released the synthetic-merge QA claim. The unchanged diagnostic now passes both cases, including literal same-line
please use /impl, on GitHub’s existing merge99b5739268a9aeb1fc9ae9251984892341b74fcd. Independent exact-byte rerun also passes 2/2. The old-head failure is preserved but must not be treated as a current-main trigger defect or a need for duplicate implementation.Executed this stage: 160/160 baseline cases across five files, plus producer diagnostic 2/2 and independent diagnostic 2/2: 162 unique cases, 164 successful case executions. Fresh frozen installation uses Effect 4.0.4 and committed patches, with lifecycle scripts disabled. All 28,079 original source files remained unchanged; all 3,515 dependency symlinks resolve within the fresh source. Previous owner-head workspace/evidence also remained unchanged.
Published reviewed three-file packet at verified remote
57c238f3e060faa9153ea5ab5091e342d0362e5b. All three files match approved bytes; only opt-in evidence files were added. Fork main stays339179f50a84dc599cce373dbb48f172f182f44e.Qualification boundary: synthetic merge base is 21 commits behind inspected main
3ff452bd65adf758e68b886d1e3778ae1ec7d970, not runtime-tested current main. This proves discovery/helper composition using synthetic installed-plugin files and fixture command inventory. Actual React/browser selection, insertion, provider handshake and dispatch remain unverified. Earlier diagnostic-placement TS6307 and lint-plugin dependency limits remain disclosed; this is not a merge-ready default test. No controlled single-change RED/GREEN claim: the two tested snapshots have different source/dependencies. Raw logs stay local; exact hashes and commands are in receipt.json.The independent test used ordinary local execution with isolated HOME/TMP and offline package-manager settings. An optional no-op namespace probe failed and was not retried; kernel network isolation is not claimed.
Credit: Maria (maria-rcks), Moinax and shivamhwp for plugin discovery; Bil0000 for the already-merged inline trigger. No production fix, origin action, merge or default-branch write. Next highest-value proof is actual composer selection/insertion and the real plugin flow on a freshly qualified integrated revision.
kvnloo commentedon Oct 15, 2026
Claiming bounded editor-component QA on the previously qualified synthetic merge, not current main. Current owner head remains b633c9c; PR base has advanced to 6cd02e9, so the revision boundary remains explicit.
Run the existing ComposerPromptEditorTiptap.navigation.test.tsx baseline, then an opt-in four-case diagnostic: same-line/prior-line completion in rich/plain modes. Exercise actual discovery, inventory/search, replacement/cursor helpers and the imported React/Tiptap editor through controlled updates; verify semantic skill node, serialized text, cursor and subsequent typing. This does not exercise ChatComposer's embedded menu callback, a browser, provider handshake or dispatch. Any pure dispatch-planner check will be labeled separately.
One producer, maximum 15 minutes and 256 MiB new artifacts, using installed frozen dependencies. No installs, production edits, copied source closures, default-branch changes or upstream actions. Preserve all original files and earlier packets; retain diagnostic as opt-in .tsx.txt. Independent review required before publication. Credit Maria (maria-rcks), Moinax and shivamhwp for discovery, and Bil0000 for inline triggers. No global capacity assertion.
kvnloo commentedon Oct 15, 2026
Completed and released bounded component QA. The real mounted React/Tiptap editor preserves the namespaced discovered skill, prefix, serialized chip, caret and subsequent editor-command text in all four same-line/prior-line × rich/plain cases. The pure Claude dispatch planner recognizes the resulting token separately; no provider call occurred.
Existing navigation baseline 9/9; final diagnostic 4/4; independent exact-byte rerun 4/4. Stage counts: 13 unique cases, 21 reported executions, 17 passing and four initial harness-assertion failures. Those failures were an incomplete expected accessible label, not a product defect. One earlier baseline invocation was interrupted before reported tests by our disk-watchdog temporary-file race; preserved in receipt. No product RED/GREEN claim.
Published and read back all three evidence files, exactly matching independent reviewer-approved bytes. Remote branch verified at 0d9b411. Only evidence files added; main remains 339179f. All 28,079 synthetic-source originals, 27,746 previous owner-head originals and 20 prior evidence files preserved.
Boundary: pinned synthetic merge 99b5739 only. The harness selects the result and supplies controlled editor props; ChatComposer menu callback/race guards, actual browser events, current main, provider transport and live plugin execution remain unverified. Four unsuppressed React flushSync lifecycle warnings occur per diagnostic run; no demonstrated user-visible consequence. Lint/typecheck not rerun, opt-in test packaging remains non-merge-ready.
Credit Maria (maria-rcks), Moinax, shivamhwp and Bil0000. Raw log hashes, reproducible commands and failure history are in receipt.json. No implementation change, upstream post, dependency install or hardware action.