You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
OpenNeuro (on*) mirrors miss electrodes.tsv/coordsystem, breaking the scalp topomap #855
The EEG viewer's scalp topomap renders only when it can resolve ≥3 electrode positions: measured coordinates the converter embeds from electrodes.tsv/coordsystem.json, or, failing that, channel labels that match a standard 10-20/10-10/10-05 montage. EGI geodesic labels (E1..E128) match no standard montage, so an HBN recording with no measured positions gets no topomap (correct, by design — better than a wrong head map).
Two copies of the same HBN data diverge in exactly this file set:
The user uploaded both from the same equipment; the OpenNeuro mirror import dropped (or never carried) the per-recording electrode positions. Same HBN data, but the mirror can't show a topo.
Asks
During on* OpenNeuro import, preserve *_electrodes.tsv + *_coordsystem.json when the source has them.
Where the OpenNeuro source genuinely lacks them but the cap is a known geodesic/standard net (e.g. GSN-HydroCel-129), consider attaching a canonical montage at import so the topomap (and any montage-based QA) can render.
Forensic update — the import is faithful; source lacks the files
Checked the OpenNeuro source directly (2026-06-28):
GET s3.amazonaws.com/openneuro.org/ds005516/sub-NDARAB678VYW/eeg/sub-..._channels.tsv -> 200
GET .../sub-..._electrodes.tsv -> 404
GET .../sub-..._coordsystem.json -> 404
So ds005516 on OpenNeuro ships no electrodes.tsv / coordsystem.json — only channels.tsv. The NEMAR on005516 import faithfully mirrored that (electrodes.tsv: 0, channels.tsv: 3397). This is not an import-drop bug; there is nothing to preserve. The NEMAR-curated nm000103 has electrodes.tsv because it was added during curation, not because the OpenNeuro copy had them.
Revised fix: viewer montage fallback (website), not import synthesis
HBN uses the EGI GSN-HydroCel-129 net (labels E1..E128 + Cz), which doesn't resolve against the viewer's vendored STANDARD_1005 set, so no topomap. The right fix mirrors the existing 10-20 fallback: extend the website viewer's standardMontageFor / STANDARD_1005 mechanism to recognize EGI (and BioSemi) named-net labels and project their canonical positions, flagged estimated: true (same caveat the 10-20 fallback already uses). This is additive, mutates no scientific data, and fixes the whole class of named-net datasets that ship no electrodes.tsv — not just on005516.
Synthesizing electrodes.tsv into the dataset at import (the original framing) is the heavier, more opinionated alternative and is not preferred.
Action: re-scope to the website viewer (src/lib/eeg-viewer/standard-montage.ts). Keeping this issue open as the tracking item; will link the website PR.
Implemented as the viewer named-net fallback in website PR nemarOrg/website#136 (EGI GSN-HydroCel-129/257 + BioSemi 128/256 canonical positions, flagged estimated). Validated against real HBN E1..E128+Cz labels.
Activity
neuromechanist commentedon Jun 28, 2026
Forensic update — the import is faithful; source lacks the files
Checked the OpenNeuro source directly (2026-06-28):
So ds005516 on OpenNeuro ships no
electrodes.tsv/coordsystem.json— onlychannels.tsv. The NEMARon005516import faithfully mirrored that (electrodes.tsv: 0, channels.tsv: 3397). This is not an import-drop bug; there is nothing to preserve. The NEMAR-curatednm000103has electrodes.tsv because it was added during curation, not because the OpenNeuro copy had them.Revised fix: viewer montage fallback (website), not import synthesis
HBN uses the EGI GSN-HydroCel-129 net (labels
E1..E128+Cz), which doesn't resolve against the viewer's vendoredSTANDARD_1005set, so no topomap. The right fix mirrors the existing 10-20 fallback: extend the website viewer'sstandardMontageFor/STANDARD_1005mechanism to recognize EGI (and BioSemi) named-net labels and project their canonical positions, flaggedestimated: true(same caveat the 10-20 fallback already uses). This is additive, mutates no scientific data, and fixes the whole class of named-net datasets that ship noelectrodes.tsv— not just on005516.Synthesizing
electrodes.tsvinto the dataset at import (the original framing) is the heavier, more opinionated alternative and is not preferred.Action: re-scope to the website viewer (
src/lib/eeg-viewer/standard-montage.ts). Keeping this issue open as the tracking item; will link the website PR.neuromechanist commentedon Jun 28, 2026
Implemented as the viewer named-net fallback in website PR nemarOrg/website#136 (EGI GSN-HydroCel-129/257 + BioSemi 128/256 canonical positions, flagged estimated). Validated against real HBN
E1..E128+Czlabels.