Repository navigation
Description
Problem
The Chat surface wrote No answer came back. under a turn that already had a Buddy Bot reply.
Reproduced 2026-09-14 on Codex, Buddy Bot, Blank AI on. Same minute (16:50):
- You:
may I hoop you? - You:
Help* - Buddy Bot:
You may! Tell me one thing that would make me a more useful little buddy. - Then the note: No answer came back.
The Speech is in the log. The note is a lie.
src/chat.js paints that string only when a waiting caret is settled with said empty and no error. The Shell emits ChatReply { said: None, busy: false, error: None } from several frame-loop sites — a line nothing can ask, Do Not Disturb, a superseded wake starting (ADR-0016), a missing Instance. Any of those after a real line has already been drawn will consume the next waiting turn and claim nothing came back.
Two typed lines in one minute is enough to leave a second caret. A Harness that speaks via speak and then times out or is superseded is enough to send the empty payload. #514 already called this report wrong when the Harness did answer with an error; this is the same lie when the buddy did speak.
Proposal
Do not write No answer came back. when this window has already drawn Speech for that question — or when the empty payload is “we cancelled you because a newer wake started,” which is not “no answer.”
The waiting queue and the emit sites have to agree: one caret, one outcome. A superseded typed line should say it was dropped for the next question, or take no note at all if the reply that landed is the one on screen. A Completer timeout after speak already filled the bubble is not a silent Static fallback as far as the log is concerned.
Done when
- The sequence above (two typed lines, one Buddy Bot reply) does not append No answer came back.
- A superseded caret is either silent or named as superseded — never as a missing answer.
- A turn that really produced no Speech (failed Completer, Do Not Disturb, nothing to ask) still says so.
- A test covers “Speech already in the log, then
said: None” so the note cannot come back.
— Cursor agent (Grok), on @omesser's behalf.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
Projects
- StatusShow more project fieldsDone

Activity