Skip to content
Closed
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
24 changes: 12 additions & 12 deletions docs/research/alternatives.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -48,7 +48,7 @@ CONTEXT.md vocabulary. ai-buddy column is honest about what is and is not built.

| Capability | ai-buddy | Desktop Mate | VPet | Shimeji-ee | Desktop Pet | OpenPets | MateEngine |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Harness integrations (ACP Completer) | ✅ (claude/codex/cursor-agent/grok/hermes/opencode/pi/goose named+verified; + custom) | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ |
| Harness integrations (ACP Completer) | ✅ (claude/codex/cursor-agent/grok/hermes/opencode/pi/goose named+verified; pi handshake HTTP MCP false; + custom) | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ |
| MCP server (buddy-side tools) | ✅ (loopback HTTP + stdio fallback) | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ |
| AI chat integration | ✅ (Summon chat surface shipped; #17 tracks polish/bugs) | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ (OpenAI) | ✅ (plugin + ctx.ai) | ✅ (built-in LLM) |
| BYO model / API key | ✅ (Settings + env vars) | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ (OpenAI) | ✅ (Anthropic/OpenAI/Ollama) | ❌ |
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -418,14 +418,13 @@ sources).

The mascot has an authored personality file (`personality.txt`) and a Director
that picks Behaviors and spoken lines non-deterministically. The Character talks
in-character while living on your windows — not Clippy (no claiming machine
abilities, no promising actions). Not a chat-first app — Summon chat exists
in-character while living on your windows. Not a chat-first app — Summon chat exists
(#17 tracks polish/bugs), but idle personality-driven speech is the product center.
Director proposes a Behavior name and
optional spoken line; Static weights when no Completer is configured, HTTP
Completer stand-in with API key/local server, Harness ACP Completer shipped
(#433 2026-09-07, named claude/codex/cursor-agent/grok/hermes/opencode/pi/goose rows + custom ACP
command per #556 2026-09-08; pi verified #628 2026-09-11; grok verified #587 2026-09-09; codex verified #623 2026-09-14; cursor-agent verified #762 2026-09-16; goose verified #971 2026-09-24). Each Instance has its own Director and
command per #556 2026-09-08; pi verified #628 2026-09-11, handshake advertises HTTP MCP false; grok verified #587 2026-09-09; codex verified #623 2026-09-14; cursor-agent verified #762 2026-09-16; goose verified #971 2026-09-24). Each Instance has its own Director and
seed — two of the same Character don't move or speak in lockstep. Each Instance
has its own user-authored Instance Prompt layer (#531 2026-09-08, ADR-0012)
strengthening multi-instance personality differentiation; personality.txt remains
Expand All @@ -436,13 +435,14 @@ package-authored.
that picks idle Behaviors + spoken lines non-deterministically, in-character.
Completer contract: Behavior name on one line, optional spoken line on the
next. `talk` animation plays when a proposal includes it. Universal rules
(stay in character, bubble length, no claiming machine abilities) injected in
`character_prompt`, not in the file. Unparsable reply becomes speech; failed
(stay in character, bubble length) injected in `character_prompt`, not in the
file (#987 2026-09-20). When asked for something, the Director invites tool use
in one sentence. Unparsable reply becomes speech; failed
wake falls back to Static. Engine keeps the sprite alive while the model
thinks. Static weights when no Completer configured; HTTP Completer stand-in
with API key/local server; Harness ACP Completer shipped (#433 2026-09-07,
named claude/codex/cursor-agent/grok/hermes/opencode/pi/goose rows + custom ACP command per
#556 2026-09-08; pi verified #628 2026-09-11; grok verified #587 2026-09-09; codex verified #623 2026-09-14; cursor-agent verified #762 2026-09-16; goose verified #971 2026-09-24). No other desktop pet ships authored personality
#556 2026-09-08; pi verified #628 2026-09-11, handshake advertises HTTP MCP false; grok verified #587 2026-09-09; codex verified #623 2026-09-14; cursor-agent verified #762 2026-09-16; goose verified #971 2026-09-24). No other desktop pet ships authored personality
+ Director-driven non-deterministic idle speech.

2. **Spatial differentiators (shipped).** Ballistic physics (gravity arcs, throw,
Expand All @@ -452,7 +452,7 @@ package-authored.
3. **Agent integrations (shipped).** Harness ACP Completer (#433 2026-09-07)
speaks to a spawned Harness as the session Completer; named claude/codex/
cursor-agent/grok/hermes/opencode/pi/goose rows + custom ACP command (#556 2026-09-08; pi
verified #628 2026-09-11, Chat-only / no MCP forward; grok verified #587 2026-09-09; codex verified
verified #628 2026-09-11, handshake advertises HTTP MCP false; whether Pi lists ai-buddy tools unmeasured #984 per #1007; grok verified #587 2026-09-09; codex verified
#623 2026-09-14; cursor-agent verified #762 2026-09-16; goose verified #971 2026-09-24). MCP server shipped (#117/#497 era +
#491 2026-09-08) serving loopback HTTP so Harness `speak` lands on screen;
`ai-buddy-mcp` stdio remains fallback. Summon chat surface shipped; #17 tracks polish/bugs. OpenPets
Expand All @@ -476,7 +476,7 @@ package-authored.
2. **Agent integrations shipped.** Desktop Pet has OpenAI chat (vendor-only
evidence). OpenPets has MCP + plugin SDK v3 + 9 official plugins (1,130 stars,
verifiable). MateEngine has built-in AI (QWEN 2.5 1.5b LLM), not BYO agent
attach. ai-buddy's Harness ACP Completer (#433 2026-09-07) + MCP server
attach. ai-buddy's Harness ACP Completer (#433 2026-09-07, pi handshake advertises HTTP MCP false per #1007) + MCP server
(loopback HTTP + stdio fallback, #117/#491/#497 2026-09-08) + Summon chat are shipped; #17 tracks polish/bugs.

3. **Distribution reach.** Desktop Mate, VPet, and MateEngine are on Steam;
Expand All @@ -490,17 +490,17 @@ package-authored.
- **~** = documented not shipped (MateEngine
macOS PR #551 open) OR partial (Shimeji-ee/OpenPets physics kind: gravity but
not ballistic Perch riding) OR unverified (no named ai-buddy Harness row
is in that state today; codex verified #623, pi verified #628, grok verified
is in that state today; codex verified #623, pi verified #628 handshake fact, grok verified
#587, cursor-agent verified #762, goose verified #971).
- **❌** = not found in cited sources as of 2026-09-24.
- **❌** = not found in cited sources as of 2026-09-25.
- Alternative columns are vendor claims unless a review/issue/Steam page is
cited. Desktop Pet has vendor-only evidence (no independent reviews). MateEngine
has Steam 974 reviews 97% + GitHub 3,532 stars.

## Sources

Capabilities marked ✅, ~, or ❌ for ai-buddy are verified against docs/SPEC.md,
DESIGN.md, README.md, ADR-0008, and `git log` on main as of September 24, 2026 (Harness `goose` named+verified per #971; prior: cursor-agent #762, pi #628, grok #587, codex #623).
DESIGN.md, README.md, ADR-0008, and `git log` on main as of September 25, 2026 (Harness `goose` named+verified per #971; prior: cursor-agent #762, pi #628 handshake fact per #1007, grok #587, codex #623; Director tool invitation #987).
Similar projects verified against Steam pages (Desktop Mate [App ID
3301060](https://store.steampowered.com/app/3301060/Desktop_Mate/) English
reviews Mixed 61% of 5,278; VPet-Simulator [App ID
Expand Down
Loading