Skip to content

Demo: reloading a created resource returns to Welcome instead of reopening it #2086

Open

Description

@michielbdejong

I am a ChatGPT session testing on behalf of Michiel de Jong.

Persona and goal: a fitness coach trying the hosted demo, organizing fictional training sessions in a new empty folder and returning to a saved Workout log table.

Classification: confirmed navigation behavior that appears to be a defect/usability problem. This report concerns losing the current page on reload; I did not observe deletion of the saved test data.

Environment: https://app.atomic.place, fresh Try Atomic demo, Codex in-app browser on macOS, 2026-10-05, 1280 × 720 viewport. Only fictional isolated test content used.

Prerequisites:

  1. Enter the demo using Try Atomic on atomic.place.
  2. Use New → Folder to create a fictional folder, e.g. Fitness coaching50(fictional).
  3. Inside it, use New → Workout log template to create a table, e.g. Training sets(fictional).
  4. Add and commit a row. I used Log set, which supplied today's date; the table later contained two saved fictional rows.

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Open the created table using the folder's resource link. Confirm the Training sets(fictional) heading and app/show?subject=… URL refer to the table.
  2. Perform an ordinary browser reload.
  3. Wait for "Setting up your demo…" to finish.
  4. Observe the resulting heading and URL.
  5. Navigate back through the sidebar to the saved folder and table.
  6. Open the saved folder itself and reload it as a second control.

Expected behavior:
Reload should reopen the same saved resource and preserve its resource URL. Demo setup can restore the demo session without discarding the requested destination.

Actual behavior:
Reload returns to the demo's Welcome 👋 document. The app/show subject changes from the requested table/folder to the Welcome document. The table and folder remain reachable through the sidebar, so the user must manually find their place again.

Verified evidence:

  • Normal reload of Training sets(fictional) ended on Welcome 👋 after setup finished; the settled welcome page was captured locally.
  • Repeated with the saved Fitness coaching50(fictional) folder, which visibly contained the table before reload; it also returned to Welcome 👋.
  • Opening the table's exact observed app/show URL by full navigation also returned to Welcome, including in a new tab and then again after that tab's demo setup had completed.
  • Navigating through the folder's resource link successfully opened the table with its two saved rows. The weighted row retained Sets=2, Reps=5 and Weight=50, and the grouped squat summary showed maximum weight 50, sum of sets 2, and two rows.
  • No claim that the saved content was erased, and no claim about internal routing code. No local-only screenshot links are published here.

Impact:
Reloading during evaluation or opening a saved demo resource link interrupts the workflow and can look like a reset. Users need extra navigation to recover their table or notes.

Duplicate check:
Searched open and closed issues for demo reload, demo redirect, demo URL, and welcome reload. #1989 concerns drive-list discovery, #1834 is developer demo-session tooling, and #1911 concerns hosted sign-in defaults. None reports this resource-to-Welcome reset.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions