Repository navigation
docs: Record the Homebrew tap shape for the macOS app - #1259
Conversation
Co-authored-by: Oded Messer <odedmesser@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Oded Messer <odedmesser@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Oded Messer <odedmesser@gmail.com>
omesser
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Soft CLEARED Soft (a) settling
Tip 4bb4efb82cd17458c9aae5085741aba009376eb3 on cursor/research-homebrew-release-shape-e12a.
Soft ledger
- (a) CI/checks — Settling (no reds;
windowsstill in progress;build/renderer/checks (ubuntu-latest)/checks (macos-latest)success;deployskipped) - (b) scope/intent — Met (single file
docs/research/homebrew-release-shape.md; durable Homebrew shape after #1204) - (c) correctness vs claim — Met (
packaging/homebrew/Casks/fidget.rb,docs/DEVELOPMENT.mdHomebrew, releasehomebrewjob +HOMEBREW_TAP_DEPLOY_KEY/ bump-verify-publish /sync-tap-tag, andsigningIdentity: "-"match; obsolete raw-URL / tap-lag gaps absent) - (d) docs/tests anchors — Met (preamble pins
207fe9f0; no line-number cites;tests/research-anchors.test.jsunchanged) - (e) hygiene — Met (no Closes; notes #1204 already on
main)
Soft-FIX: None
— Cursor agent (Architect), on @omesser's behalf.
omesser
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Soft CLEARED confirm Soft
Tip 4bb4efb82cd17458c9aae5085741aba009376eb3 on cursor/research-homebrew-release-shape-e12a.
Flip: Soft CLEARED Soft (a) settling COMMENT 5388556079 → Soft CLEARED confirm Soft (Soft (a) now fully green).
Soft ledger
- (a) CI/checks — Met (MERGEABLE/CLEAN; PR Tests success —
build/renderer/windows/checks (ubuntu-latest)/checks (macos-latest); Pagesbuildsuccess /deployskipped) - (b) scope/intent — Met (single file
docs/research/homebrew-release-shape.md; durable Homebrew shape after #1204) - (c) correctness vs claim — Met (
packaging/homebrew/Casks/fidget.rb,docs/DEVELOPMENT.mdHomebrew, releasehomebrewjob +HOMEBREW_TAP_DEPLOY_KEY/ bump-verify-publish /sync-tap-tag, andsigningIdentity: "-"match; obsolete raw-URL / tap-lag gaps absent) - (d) docs/tests anchors — Met (preamble pins
207fe9f0; no line-number cites;tests/research-anchors.test.jsunchanged) - (e) hygiene — Met (no Closes; notes #1204 already on
main)
Soft-FIX: None
— Cursor agent (Architect), on @omesser's behalf.
Co-authored-by: Oded Messer <odedmesser@gmail.com>
omesser
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Soft CLEARED Soft (a) settling
Tip c946307bd075a523cce21ac0c2b460315f04c100 on cursor/research-homebrew-release-shape-e12a (moved from Soft CLEARED confirm Soft COMMENT 5388564023 at 4bb4efb82cd17458c9aae5085741aba009376eb3).
Tip delta: c946307bd075 — drop named DVC formula example; keep generalized cask-vs-formula rule for Fidget.app.
Soft ledger
- (a) CI/checks — Settling (no reds;
renderersuccess;windows/checks (ubuntu-latest)/checks (macos-latest)/ Pagesbuildin progress;deploynot yet; mergeableunstable) - (b) scope/intent — Met (single file
docs/research/homebrew-release-shape.md; durable Homebrew shape after #1204; Oded ask for no named-CLI analogy met) - (c) correctness vs claim — Met (
packaging/homebrew/Casks/fidget.rb,docs/DEVELOPMENT.mdHomebrew, releasehomebrewjob +HOMEBREW_TAP_DEPLOY_KEY/ bump-verify-publish /sync-tap-tag, andsigningIdentity: "-"match at207fe9f0; obsolete raw-URL / tap-lag / DVC-named gaps absent) - (d) docs/tests anchors — Met (preamble pins
207fe9f0; no line-number cites;tests/research-anchors.test.jsunchanged) - (e) hygiene — Met (no Closes; notes #1204 already on
main)
Soft-FIX: None
— Cursor agent (Architect), on @omesser's behalf.
omesser
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Soft CLEARED Soft (a) settling
Tip c946307bd075a523cce21ac0c2b460315f04c100 on cursor/research-homebrew-release-shape-e12a.
Re-gate after tip move from Soft CLEARED tip 4bb4efb82cd17458c9aae5085741aba009376eb3 (COMMENT 5388564023 / Soft CLEARED Soft (a) settling 5388556079). Tip removes the DVC named-CLI example and states the formula-vs-cask rule in general terms.
Soft ledger
- (a) CI/checks — Settling (no reds;
windowsstill in progress;build/renderer/checks (ubuntu-latest)/checks (macos-latest)success; Pagesbuildsuccess /deployskipped; MERGEABLE/unstable) - (b) scope/intent — Met (single file
docs/research/homebrew-release-shape.md; durable Homebrew shape after #1204; tip delta is DVC removal + generalized formula vs cask) - (c) correctness vs claim — Met (
packaging/homebrew/Casks/fidget.rb,docs/DEVELOPMENT.mdHomebrew, releasehomebrewjob +HOMEBREW_TAP_DEPLOY_KEY/ bump-verify-publish /sync-tap-tag, andsigningIdentity: "-"match; obsolete raw-URL / tap-lag gaps absent; no DVC mentions remain in tip) - (d) docs/tests anchors — Met (preamble pins
207fe9f0; no fidget line-number cites;tests/research-anchors.test.jsunchanged) - (e) hygiene — Met (no Closes; notes #1204 already on
main)
Soft-FIX: None
— Cursor agent (Architect), on @omesser's behalf.
Why
#1204 has merged. The research note still described unpublished gaps from before that merge, including a raw cask URL and a tap that lagged the pull request tip. Those claims are false on
main, and leaving them in the repo would record a review that the merge already settled.What changed
docs/research/homebrew-release-shape.mddescribes the merged tree at207fe9f0. It keeps the durable findings: a third-party tap plus a.appdisk-image cask is the shape for this ad-hoc-signed build, whyhomebrew/caskstays closed, howbrew tap omesser/fidgetclonesomesser/homebrew-fidget, the install linebrew install --cask omesser/fidget/fidget, and the Release job that pushes the tap withHOMEBREW_TAP_DEPLOY_KEY.Homebrew sends a native macOS
.appon a disk image to a cask, and open-source command-line software to a formula inhomebrew/core. Fidget shipsFidget.appvia DMG, so the package is a cask in a third-party tap, not a formula.The pre-merge gap list is gone.
tests/research-anchors.test.jsis unchanged: it does not name this note's sources, and the note no longer cites line numbers. The preamble still names207fe9f0.How to verify
Read the note against
packaging/homebrew/Casks/fidget.rb,docs/DEVELOPMENT.md("Homebrew"), and thehomebrewjob in.github/workflows/release.ymlat207fe9f0.Notes
Does not merge. #1204 is already on
main.— Cursor agent, on @omesser's behalf.