You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
A Character says things only through its reply, with no MCP speak tool #1935
A Character says things through one channel: its reply. There is no MCP speak tool.
The parser already sorts some parts of a reply into other kinds. Everything else is what the Character says, and it streams to both the Chat surface and the bubble. These parts are something else:
Thinking prose: prose before a behavior: line goes to the Thinking row.
Startup banners: known Harness banners, such as Pi's, are dropped.
Bare Behavior names: a reply that only names a Behavior plays it and says nothing.
The Behavior line: the behavior: or Name | line line itself picks the Behavior. Text after the pipe is said.
So there is no second channel, no aside flag on Chat rows, and no gate that accepts or declines each line. Double speech, ordering between two channels, late speak lines and speech from outside a turn stop being problems, because only one channel exists.
Naming
Reserve the word "speech" for a future tool call to a real audio speech engine. Today's text path does not use that name, in code, docs, ADRs or GLOSSARY.md. Pick a plain word for it, such as "said" or "line".
Long-running work
A Character stays lively during long work through an optional one-line addition to its own prompt, as in #1934. There are no system prompt or infrastructure changes for this.
To do
Remove speak from the MCP tool surface and its dispatch in crates/core/src/dispatch.rs.
Amend or supersede the ADRs that assume a speak tool or two speech channels: ADR-0026 and its promise about speak, ADR-0016 where it covers late lines, plus ADR-0003 and ADR-0023, which list speak among the tools.
Update docs/harness.md, docs/SPEC.md, docs/DEVELOPMENT.md and GLOSSARY.md to match, including the naming rule above.
Progress after #1953 (merged as 4ad3516), checked on main:
Done when
No code, doc or ADR describes speak as a live tool or a second channel. list_tools() in crates/core/src/tools.rs no longer has speak, and crates/core/src/dispatch.rs:524-531 pins 8 tools with no speak. ADR-0040 records the decision, and ADR-0003, 0016, 0023 and 0026, docs/harness.md, docs/SPEC.md, docs/DEVELOPMENT.md and GLOSSARY.md no longer list it. What's left is history (docs/harness.md:426 says "a tool since removed (ADR-0040)"), GLOSSARY.md:187 (_Avoid_: speak), the near_reaction = "speak" cursor reaction, and "speak" as a plain verb.
The last box is done: #1988 (merged as 07b406d) renamed the text path to Dialogue in code, closing #1955. The reply parser, chat settle (action: "dialogue"), the action-log result, and the landing page now say Dialogue. SpeechBubble and mod speech stay, since they are the Speech bubble, and Apple SpeechAnalyzer is real audio. Both Done-when items are met on main.
Activity
omesser commentedon Oct 30, 2026
Progress after #1953 (merged as 4ad3516), checked on
main:Done when
speakas a live tool or a second channel.list_tools()incrates/core/src/tools.rsno longer hasspeak, andcrates/core/src/dispatch.rs:524-531pins 8 tools with nospeak. ADR-0040 records the decision, and ADR-0003, 0016, 0023 and 0026,docs/harness.md,docs/SPEC.md,docs/DEVELOPMENT.mdandGLOSSARY.mdno longer list it. What's left is history (docs/harness.md:426says "a tool since removed (ADR-0040)"),GLOSSARY.md:187(_Avoid_: speak), thenear_reaction = "speak"cursor reaction, and "speak" as a plain verb.speech(e.g.crates/core/src/speech.rs). That's Rename the speech identifiers for the text path to dialogue #1955, which waits on feat(engine): Apply the drive intent and the possession switch #1923.The "Revisit #1375" to-do is done: #1375 has a comment that moves narration during long work into the Character's own Personality Prompt (#1934).
Leaving this open until #1955 lands.
— Cursor agent (P. Coder), on @omesser's behalf.
omesser commentedon Oct 31, 2026
The last box is done: #1988 (merged as
07b406d) renamed the text path to Dialogue in code, closing #1955. The reply parser, chat settle (action: "dialogue"), the action-log result, and the landing page now say Dialogue.SpeechBubbleandmod speechstay, since they are the Speech bubble, and AppleSpeechAnalyzeris real audio. Both Done-when items are met onmain.— Cursor agent (Coder), on @omesser's behalf.